Relations to the intraclass correlation coefficient of the ratings data are pointed out. Barnhart department of biostatistics, the rollins school of public health of emory university, 1518 clifton road ne, atlanta, georgia. Data were analysed using intraclass correlation coefficient icc. Reliability of basal plasma vasopressin concentrations in. Methods for evaluating the agreement between diagnostic tests. We also estimated the pre and posttraining concordance between the pe teams median vas ratings and the research teams consensus vas ratings by computing the concordance correlation coefficient p c. Little is known about the repeatability of cell counts in the bal obtained. How to use spsslins concordance correlation coefficient. Measures of concordance for assessing agreement in ratings. To test reproducibility, we assessed the correlation to treatment related. Lins concordance correlation coefficient ccc is the concordance between a new test or measurement y and a gold standard test or measurement x.
Cell counts were obtained following a nonbronchoscopic lavage. Stability analysis of ct radiomic features with respect to. Reproducibility of intract rfs, based on coefficient of variation, ranged from 89. Use of the concordance correlation coefficient as a measure of reproducibility has gained popularity in practice since its introduction by lin 1989, biometrics45, 255268. To evaluate the relative contribution of different magnetic resonance imaging mri sequences for the extraction of radiomics features in a cohort. Combining multiple magnetic resonance imaging sequences. Deep learningbased image conversion of ct reconstruction. The concordance correlation coefficient ccc was used in our study because it provides a robust we thank sabour and ghassemi for their interest in our recent publication. Lawrence ikuei lin 1989 a concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility. Effect of ergonomics training on agreement between expert.
This study proposes a desirable reproducibility index, to be called a concordance correlation coefficient, which evaluates the agreement between two readings from the same sample by measuring the variation from the 450 line through the origin the concordance line. The column identifier for the true results that is numeric. Agreement and reproducibility of measurements were evaluated using bland and altman analysis and calculation of concordance correlation coefficient, while c rs measurements before and after median sternotomy were compared using paired ttest. Alternative estimators for evaluating agreement and reproducibility.
Iso defined repeatability and reproducibility as precision under the repeatability and. It calculates the value of lins concordance correlation coefficient. The level of statistical significance was set at p reproducibility. The ccc macro is presented for computation of the concordance correlation coefficient ccc, a common measure of reproducibility. This random effect accounts for the repeated measures for each subject. Mcbride, gb 2005 a proposal for strengthofagreement criteria for lins concordance correlation coefficient. Evaluation of the reliability and repeatability of. Measurement variability in radiomic features was evaluated using the concordance correlation coefficient ccc. Validity is historically assessed by the correlation coefficient between the new. Overall concordance correlation coefficient for evaluating agreement among multiple observers. The lin concordance correlation coefficient was also computed as a measure of true agreement with. A p concordance correlation coefficient ccc and blandaltman analyses were used to evaluate reproducibility of measurements. A note on the concordance correlation coefficient thomas. For lung cancer, interobserver variability with respect to manual versus.
To evaluate the subjectinvestigator agreement on the unified parkinsons disease rating scale updrs subsections i and ii. The striatal, caudate, and putamen nondisplaceable binding potential bp nd were calculated. Lins method is applicable for studies evaluating two raterstwo methods without replications. The macro has been produced in both sas and r, and a detailed presentation of the macro input and output for the sas program is included. Intermethod, intraobserver, and interobserver agreements were tested by using blandaltman analysis and the lin concordance correlation coefficient r c. They also plotted the concordance of cartilage cap measurement with ct and mr imaging see figure 5 but did not provide the concordance correlation coefficients. Crude pearsons correlation coefficients between the first and the second ffq. Crude pearsons correlation coefficients between the first and the second ffq ranged from 0. Overall concordance correlation coefficient for evaluating. The concordance correlation coefficient measures the agreement between two variables e.
Google scholar nasreddine zs, phillips na, bedirian v, charbonneau s, whitehead v, collin i, chertkow h 2005. Recently, lin 2000 issued an erratum reporting a number of typographical errors in his seminal 1989 paper. Modeling concordance correlation via gee to evaluate. Correlation only identifies the relationship between two variables, regression analysis is required to determine the value of one variable in terms of another. A new reproducibility index is developed and studied. The proposed concordance measures provide the basis for testing the agreement between two or more methods, instruments or respondents in biometric research or market research surveys. Lin, a concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility.
Dai feng, richard baumgartner and vladimir svetnik 2014 a short note on jackknifing the concordance correlation coefficient. It can be further written as the product of the accuracy and the precision coefficients. Biometrics 57, 931940 september 2001 modeling concordance correlation via gee to evaluate reproducibility huiman x. This concordance correlation coefficient evaluates the degree to which pairs fall reproducible if it is performed. This statistic quantifies the agreement between these two measures of the same variable e. Differences between methods were tested by using repeatedmeasures analysis of variance. Reproducibility and relative validity of a foodfrequency.
A guideline of selecting and reporting intraclass correlation coefficients for reliability research. Pc contains a measure of precision p and accuracy cb. Development and validation of a short version of the. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the reliability precision and accuracy, and repeatability of an infrared method of determining milk urea nitrogen. A ame containing the truth and estimate columns not currently used. The reference method used for the reliability assessment was a wetchemistry, enzymatic determination of milk urea nitrogen. Subjectinvestigator reproducibility of the unified. Conclusion poor reliability of basal avp concentrations suggests future work covarying avp with trait markers should proceed with careful consideration of.
The feasibility of using ctguided roi for semiquantifying. Radiomics of ct features may be nonreproducible and. The statistical properties of this estimate can be satisfactorily evaluated using an inverse hyperbolic tangent transformation. Computer programs for the concordance correlation coefficient. A concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility. To demonstrate agreement, it is mandatory to show that values measured on two successive occasions are equal at the individual level for each respondent. Het meten van kwaliteit van leven bij ernstig demente. Lins concordance correlation coefficient lin, 1989, as well as the limitsofagreement procedure bland and altman, 1986. It was first proposed by fisher4 and is defined by assuming that results of the diagnostic tests follow a oneway anova model with a random effect for subject. We then calculated lin concordance correlation coefficient, which measures the agreement between 2 variables. Lin, li 1989 a concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility.
Pdf a concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate reproducibility. Children n43 attending for elective surgery were studied. Comprehensive assessment of coronary artery disease by using firstpass analysis dynamic ct perfusion. Lins concordance calculator is used to assess the degree of agreement between two continuous variables, such as chemical or microbiological concentrations. To assess the reproducibility of using autocad software to measure the area of venous leg ulcers vlus. An assay or instrument validation attempts to evaluate the reproducibility or repeatability of. Blandaltman plots and receiver operating characteristic. The concordance correlation coefficient combines measures of both precision and accuracy to determine how far the observed data deviate from the line of perfect concordance that is, the line at 45 degrees on a square scatter plot. Pdf using autocad software to measure venous leg ulcers. This should be an unquoted column name although this argument is passed by expression and supports quasiquotation you can unquote column names. Pdf a concordance correlation coefficient to evaluate.
Rois from ct and mri were transferred to the coregistered spect for semiquantification. Further, changes in stata version 7 required modification of concord. This index is the correlation between the two readings that fall on the 45 degree line through the origin. Airway inflammation in children can be assessed by nonbronchoscopic bronchoalveolar lavage bal. Statstodo provides 1 program evaluating concordance for binary data, kuderrichardson coefficient ordinal data. Results a total of 104 patients were studied, including 54 women and 50 men, with pulmonary nodules or masses mean age, 63. Testretest, agreement, reliability, correlation, concordance coefficient, blandaltman plot. In statistics, the concordance correlation coefficient measures the agreement between two variables, e. Correlation between the measurements of serum and arterial blood gas abg electrolytes in patients admitted to the intensive care unit at king abdulaziz medical city, riyadh, saudi arabia. Values of 1 denote perfect concordance and discordance. A note on a concordance correlation coefficient to. Evaluation of reproducibility for paired functional data. A proposal for strengthofagreement criteria for lins concordance correlation coefficient hamilton, new zeland. To assess the reproducibility and validity of a foodfrequency questionnaire.
An overview on assessing agreement with continuous measurements. Like a correlation, ccc ranges from 1 to 1, with perfect agreement at 1. Comprehensive assessment of coronary artery disease by. Methods subjectinvestigator agreement was estimated at baseline and endpoint by kappa statistics for individual items and concordance correlations for subscale totals using data from two nih exploratory trials in parkinsons disease studies. It is simple to use and possesses desirable properties. Whereas pearsons correlation coefficient is immune to whether the biased or unbiased version for estimation of the variance is used, the concordance correlation coefficient is not. Computes lins 1989, 2000 concordance correlation coefficient for agreement on a continuous measure obtained by two methods. Authors responseapproach to evaluating the reliability. Statistical methods for conducting agreement comparison. The repeatability of nonbronchoscopic bronchoalveolar. Using ctguided rois had higher intra and interobserver concordance correlation coefficients, closer blandaltman biases to. The concordance correlation coefficient strikes a balance between a correlation measure insensitive to location differences and a measure of location discrepancy.
1227 770 1231 911 1380 215 754 619 332 241 98 335 249 1515 1018 592 1233 475 1022 1601 336 475 721 1090 857 1095 1316 926 162 370 1621 1221 319 252 970 902 632 797 401 1232 83 381 796